No. The SoR can be replaced by two random civilians dying, if there are two left.

nubby apollo read the rule carefully

Lingering Spirit- If the Spirit of Robin is voted to death in the first day or killed by the Murderer with his "Assassination" ability in the first night round, Friar Tuck will randomly choose one of the Civilians and make them the new Spirit of Robin.

Never call Apollo nubby. Ever.

And the game is only won by Evil when the BTTB dies, not the SoR. If 2 civilians are alive then both of them would die if the BTTB would be targeted, still leaving a chance to find the murderer. But in the situation where the SoR is Sir Guy's target, the game would just end, like the one we just played.

Kenny can you clarify my other question?

The simple answer is: Sir Guy wins.

The complex answer involving how to avoid it:

This gets complicated. Let me call Sir Guy the lyncher, since that is what his role originates from in mafia terms anyways. There's a couple of strategies involving how you deal with the lyncher. The first is that you may not lynch until you have 3-4 suspects of who the lyncher might be. In this case Koriko, Apollo, and someone else whom I'm too lazy to look up were cases of the lyncher. You know that 1 out of 3 of those are the lyncher, you know that 1 is the witch doctor, and one might be either a random or a town role. This means you have a 2/3rds chance to provide forward progression for town.

My advice? Take it. The chances are minimal that the lyncher will have the other 2 as a target. Town people should never go for a definite lynch on day 1 (Preacher/Maid Marian), unless it's a Maid Marian Blitz to get rid of the KJD.

As for evil people, they still need to push a target day 1 if they have one. The point is to out certain roles for the murderer, remember that the murderer doesn't win if evil has a majority, murderer wins if he can kill the BttB, so witch doctor should push every day 1 regardless to out who the preacher is.

Another good thing is that Lyncher pushing on someone looks like MM pushing on KJD, or Preacher pushing on Witch Doctor. This could mean that evil eliminates him

That's how I think you guys should play against the Lyncher.

or just go back to the normal game and get rid of these 2 roles that complicate things

Yeah, we should play a game that is as derp as possible.

I'm asking you to just think. It's a psychological game. The competition on the mafia sites are 1000x more intense, and have over 70 roles to choose from a game. I know all 70 of those roles, and I compete regularly. Surely you can learn a handful with 1 curveball.

Time to start.

Soon. Kenny and I have to deal with something first, then I'm sure he will get it started.

-Apollo

we gonna start or what...

.. growing old waiting ..

why not just continue the WKRH as an on going crusade that after one game ends another begins with sign ups and each game can be a different test on what works

............problem solved....plus coud bring ore people to play over ti nd allows for more roles