If you say this is experiment...why dont you consider to ask for opinions from other players in the current world..if that would have been done that would have been honorable..
Now reading this as an outsider I'd say that is what this thread it, opinion and feedback gathered in an specific place. That doesn't mean Seth has not received feedback in game messages or PMs as well. Knowing Seth I have the utmost confidence he will make changes where needed and either scrap the idea if he considers it a failure or make tweaks to better reform it. Personally I don't see what it has to do with honor though. Just my thoughts of course.